StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Power & Privilege - Fashioning a plan - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Considering what has been written about power and privilege in America, and what I have learned over the period of this course, the scope of this paper is to bring it all together into a personal expression of my own belief system along with a strategy for affecting change…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98% of users find it useful
Power & Privilege - Fashioning a plan
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Power & Privilege - Fashioning a plan"

Patricia James YOUR Power and Privilege - Fashioning a Plan Considering what has been written about power and privilege in America, and what I have learned over the period of this course, the scope of this paper is to bring it all together into a personal expression of my own belief system along with a strategy for affecting change. First, however, I will address some of the ideas expressed by Peters and Alperovitz to frame the articulation of my own social agenda. I believe that the social issues relating to power and privilege are worthy of my personal consideration and energies. Peters and Alperovitz. I found the articles by these two writers, as well as those of Johnson, to be interesting; but I find myself somewhat critical of their bias. I agree with Peters that "[s]ystems and institutions that regulate class location are much more powerful than individuals" (Peters 1). There are certainly individuals who work hard and try to improve their lives and situations and are prevented from achieving complete success due to the resistance of the powerful; and social change efforts should be made to address those inequities. I can't accept, however, that "everyone deserves what you have; you just happen to have it" or her idea that "empowered people enrich themselves by leaving exploitative, dehumanizing work to others" (Peters 1). This position implies too much intentionality to what often is random placement within the socio-economic spectrum or the result of individual choice. As James and Robinson point out, "there are necessarily differences between people. We all perceive these differences and make judgments about others based on them..." (xv), and this is exactly what Peters does; she makes judgments about those employed in menial jobs from her perspective of upper-middle class privilege. She would never be happy bagging groceries; ergo, no one else can be either. That's just a little too simplistic. As for Alperovitz, putting his political partisanship aside, I think the fundamental idea of using the political process to address the abuse of power or privilege is an appropriate response. His observation of "America's extreme concentration of income and wealth" (1) is accurate, and a social agenda using the power of the vote is a more effective method than that of simply relying on the courts. As Schultz notes, "social reformers and activists would be better served by reconsidering how much hope was placed upon working through the courts versus investing more time to win critical victories thorough the political process" (9). The legal system certainly has its place in addressing the suppression of classes of individuals, but the political system is a better tool for social policy. It also has the benefit of being the voice of the people, rather than that of an activist judiciary or single governmental branch. What I have learned. From this course, I have come to a fresh understanding of power and privilege generally, the impact of the misuse of those concepts on the radically disenfranchised, as well as my own place within the dynamic. I don't believe that the positions taken by authors on either extreme are realistic. An individual's plight is not solely the result of his or her own choices, but neither is it necessarily the intentional infliction of harm by a bad system. Certainly, many individuals must shoulder the burden of their own choices and it is far too easy to blame the system for their condition. On the other hand, there really are those people who are neither powerful nor privileged as a result of systemic oppression or neglect. As I look at my own standing in society and the privileges I enjoy, I am aware of those who have more and those who have less. I think that everyone is both privileged and disenfranchised on some level. The distinction for me lies within the individual circumstances under consideration. The middle-class college student has more inherited privilege than the impoverished gang member, naturally. I am unwilling, however, to accept someone else's forced guilt for my condition. Am I glad that I am not homeless and living in squalid conditions Of course. Do I see my condition as a function of a biased, class system that has intentionally inflicted privilege on me No, I don't. There are too many instances of individuals rising above their disadvantaged conditions-and of people who have fallen from privilege to poverty-for me to naively accept the idea that the individual has no power at all to change their circumstances. I believe the issue is more complicated than that, and complex issues do not positively respond to over-simplified generalizations. The solution, for me, lies in a combination of behaviors that address the power/privilege paradigm. Strategy for change. My approach to resolving this issue is a mixture of individual and systemic change. If the system is ever going to change, the people within the system have to change. Accordingly, I think that children should be instructed in inclusiveness and compassion, as Peters suggests. I think racism in all forms should not be tolerated, and that educational initiatives to overcome such ignorance should be employed at all levels; schools as well as workplaces, the public forum as well as governmental sectors. I believe that those individuals who truly understand that there is abuse of power and privilege should lead by example. Rather than simply separating her garbage into paper vs. plastic, perhaps Peters could take her children on community service activities and clean up some streets. I know I can certainly find ways to be actively involved in helping those who are disenfranchised; and that is the best example of all. Finally, the legal and political processes should be incorporated to address the inequities in the system that prevent people from rising above negative circumstances. At the end of the day, power and privilege can be used by those who have them to help those who do not. Abusers of their power should be thwarted. Through education and personal example, individuals at all levels can use their power and privilege constructively. It is, in fact, the best use of both. Works Cited Alperovitz, Gar. "Taking the Offensive on Wealth." 3 Feb. 2005. The Nation. 15 Aug. 2006. . James, Larry C. and Robinson, John D. (Eds.) Diversity in Human Interactions. New York: Oxford University Press, 2003. Johnson, Allan G. Privilege, Power, and Difference. Mountain View, CA: Mayfield, 2001. Peters, Cynthia. "Talking to Kids about Class." 3 Aug. 2000. Znet Daily Commentaries. 15 Aug. 2006. . Schultz, David A. (Ed.) Leveraging the Law: Using the Courts to Achieve Social Change. New York: Peter Lang, 1998. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Power & Privilege - Fashioning a plan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Power & Privilege - Fashioning a plan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1523423-power-privilege-fashioning-a-plan
(Power & Privilege - Fashioning a Plan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Power & Privilege - Fashioning a Plan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1523423-power-privilege-fashioning-a-plan.
“Power & Privilege - Fashioning a Plan Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1523423-power-privilege-fashioning-a-plan.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Power & Privilege - Fashioning a plan

Analytical reviews

The idea that the working classes in any society are bound to rise up and forcibly seize power was naturally seen as a threat by many European commentators, and it provoked both ardent followers and severe critics.... Analytical Reviews; Part One: Marxism and Global Expansion The famous defence of communism entitled The Communiss Manifesto was written by Marx and Engels in collaboration and it was first published in London in 1848....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Representation of Women in Magazines through the Decades till Today

In fact feminists believe that media has more power in the present age and as a result has more influence on the image of women (Byerly and Ross, 2006, pp.... Representation of women in magazines through the decades till today Interactions of gender, class and race have been of deep interest to sociology and bear significance in building a social identity....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Cold War and Consumerists Mass Culture

The government policy after the war had encouraged mass purchasing power instead of coming up with measures to equalize the wealth distribution.... The essay "Cold War and Consumerists Mass Culture" explores the influence of consumerists mass culture on the economy of the United States in the post war period....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The linguistic mecanism to produce an allegorical message in a play narrative

Allegories created within any kind of work can provide countless depths of meaning to even the most simple-sounding tale, yet the idea of what an allegory is frequently confounds people.... For some, it is merely the relationship between a concrete example and an abstract thought… For others, the term goes much deeper, to include characters, props, space and even time....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Theories of Competitive Advantage

Even older sports are coming out of their staid… To go along with the current image of the sport new clothing and apparel are the demand of the day and designers are fashioning clothes are not just practical but attractive too.... New and more adventurous sports are coming to fore that require different high performance gear for their users....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Response to article AND movie

Storytelling through technology entails the involvement of animation design in fashioning characters.... This scene explains how privilege in a person may be instrumental in effecting change in a society.... Both of the entities possess a fair chance at manipulating their power to achieve unique in societies....
2 Pages (500 words) Admission/Application Essay

The Use Of The Themes Of Innocence In Fingersmith By Sarah Waters

This essay discusses the book “Fingersmith” by Sarah Waters, that is a novel about Sue Trinder, a girl who became an orphan at birth and grew up among thieves.... The girl was brought up by Mrs.... Sucksby in a rough but caring way.... hellip; The essay aims to explore the themes of innocence and knowledge as portrayed in the novel....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

The Power of the American President to Persuade

This paper "The power of the American President to Persuade" first justifies the need for a president to persuade.... It then proceeds to discuss instances where the power of persuasion has worked and where it has failed before the author gives their concluding thoughts on the subject.... In their 1960 book that has since become a modern classic in American politics, Presidential power and the Modern President, Neustadt argues that a president derives their authority not only from the Constitution but also from their persuasive abilities and the prestige associated with the presidency (Neustadt, 1960)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us